Why Did RTIC Agree to Stop Selling the Coolers That Made It Famous?
After YETI alleged that RTIC's products and marketing infringed its trade dress, designs, and patents, RTIC disputed the claims but settled before trial, accepting a payment, stop-sale, and redesigns as a path to relaunch.

Premieres November 2, 2026 at 8:00 PM CST. The video will play here after its scheduled YouTube release.
Read the evidence, decisions, and consequences behind this investigation.
The question: The Cooler War
Why Did RTIC Agree to Stop Selling the Coolers That Made It Famous?
The Houston Chronicle reported that RTIC began shipping coolers in September twenty fifteen as a lower-priced, direct-to-consumer alternative to YETI. By December twenty sixteen, the Chronicle reported that RTIC had generated nearly two hundred million dollars in revenue.
Then, just weeks later, RTIC agreed to make a financial payment, stop selling every product covered by YETI's lawsuits, and redesign its hard coolers, soft coolers, and drinkware.
That sounds like the ending. It was actually a reset.
YETI had alleged that RTIC's products and marketing crossed the line from aggressive competition into infringement of YETI's trade dress, designs, and patents. RTIC disputed YETI's claims and fought back with claims of its own. But before a trial could resolve who was right, the companies settled.
The deal ended the current cases while forcing RTIC to change the products at the center of its rise.
YETI Builds More Than a Box
Brothers Roy and Ryan Seiders founded YETI in Austin in two thousand six. YETI's origin story begins with equipment that could not stand up to the brothers' hunting and fishing interests.
Their answer was not merely another container for ice. YETI built its brand around durable coolers, outdoor use, and a distinctive premium identity.
The numbers show how valuable that identity became. YETI reported net sales of eighty-nine point nine million dollars in twenty thirteen and six hundred thirty-nine point two million dollars in twenty seventeen. In the registration statement it filed before going public, YETI also described patents, trademarks, and trade dress as critical protections for its business.
Trade dress was central to the coming fight. In YETI's complaints, the dispute was not simply about whether another company could sell a cooler that kept things cold. YETI alleged that the appearance of RTIC's products, combined with RTIC's YETI-directed comparisons, could confuse consumers about the products' source or affiliation.
That distinction matters. RTIC was entering a market YETI had helped turn premium. But RTIC was not entering quietly.
RTIC Sells the Comparison
RTIC says it was founded in Katy, Texas, in twenty fourteen on the idea that a high-quality cooler should not cost a whole paycheck. Its founders were another pair of brothers: twins John and Jim Jacobsen.
They entered with a direct challenge and a simple pitch. RTIC sold directly to consumers, emphasized lower prices, and openly compared its products with YETI's. A shopper did not need a lecture on cooler construction; the established premium product supplied the reference point, and RTIC supplied the alternative.
That approach moved quickly. Contemporary reporting says RTIC shipped its first coolers in September twenty fifteen. The same Houston Chronicle report supplied the nearly two-hundred-million-dollar revenue figure.
But the comparison that made RTIC easy to understand also made the alleged similarities easy to put in front of a judge.
One Lawsuit Becomes Three
YETI filed its first case against RTIC over hard-sided coolers in July twenty fifteen, before RTIC's reported first shipments that September. It filed a separate drinkware case in March twenty sixteen, then a soft-cooler complaint in July.
Across those cases, YETI asserted a mix of trade-dress, unfair-competition, design-patent, and related claims. YETI alleged that RTIC had imitated protectable product features and used direct comparisons in ways that could confuse buyers about source or affiliation.
Those were allegations, not findings.
RTIC disputed the claims. In its own declaratory action, RTIC asked a court to rule that it had not copied YETI's drinkware trade dress or engaged in unfair competition, and it asserted attempted-monopolization and tortious-interference claims.
Now the cooler war had two competing stories. In YETI's version, RTIC was using the visual identity YETI had spent years building. In RTIC's version, a market leader was trying to wall off legitimate competition.
A federal judge transferred RTIC's second-filed case from Houston to Austin because it substantially overlapped YETI's first-filed drinkware litigation there. And in the hard-cooler case, the parties fought over expert surveys meant to test whether consumers could be confused by the coolers' appearance and references to YETI.
The legal fight was technical and uncertain. The business question was simpler: how long should RTIC keep fighting while the products themselves remained under attack?
The Price of a Clean Exit
On February second, twenty seventeen, YETI announced that the companies and the Jacobsen brothers had reached a binding settlement.
The announced terms were unusually tangible. RTIC and the Jacobsens would make a financial payment to YETI. They would cease sales of every product subject to the lawsuits, including the hard coolers, soft coolers, and drinkware in dispute. And they would redesign those products.
Public disclosures did not state how much RTIC paid or publish the full agreement. YETI's broader financial disclosures must not be treated as a receipt for RTIC's payment.
GearJunkie quoted an RTIC statement saying the company settled to avoid the additional costs and uncertainty of continued litigation.
Most important, this was a negotiated settlement, not a trial verdict that proved every YETI allegation. A judge did not order RTIC out of business. RTIC accepted terms that ended the current cases while forcing a concrete change in what it could sell.
That is why the deal can look like both a defeat and a survival strategy. RTIC agreed to replace the disputed designs, but it gained a path to relaunch without carrying several federal cases toward trial.
Clear the Shelves, Change the Product
The stop-sale language created an apparent contradiction: why did RTIC keep selling its old products after the settlement?
YETI later told investors that its twenty seventeen competitor settlements allowed liquidation of disputed inventory at low prices. Contemporary reporting said RTIC would continue selling its remaining current products for a few months, discount many of them while supplies lasted, and launch replacement models no later than May first. That was RTIC's announced plan, not proof that every redesigned category arrived on schedule.
What is clear is that RTIC did not disappear. It continued operating and broadened its catalog beyond the products in the original fight.
The settlement changed the shape of the competition without ending it. RTIC could still compete on price, function, and direct sales. But continuing with the specific products covered by the lawsuits required the transition and redesign set out in the deal.
The cooler that made the company's comparison effortless had become the thing it had to change.
Both Brands Survive
YETI went public in October twenty eighteen, pricing its initial offering at eighteen dollars per share. That later milestone does not prove the lawsuit caused YETI's success; it shows that the premium brand continued growing after the settlement.
RTIC also remained a functioning business. Wind Point Partners acquired the company in twenty twenty, while John and Jim Jacobsen retained meaningful ownership stakes and stayed involved as senior advisers and board members.
That outcome complicates the easy version of the story. YETI did not erase its challenger, and RTIC did not secure the right to keep every disputed design. Instead, the settlement drew a line around the product identity through which RTIC had made its original comparison.
The decision that mattered in twenty seventeen was whether RTIC would keep defending the products that launched it or change them and keep the company moving.
The answer: Copy the Opportunity, Not the Identity
So, why did RTIC agree to stop selling the coolers that made it famous?
RTIC's lower-price, direct-to-consumer comparison with YETI accompanied rapid reported growth. But YETI alleged that the resemblance crossed into protected trade dress, designs, and patents. Rather than carry three product fights through continued litigation, RTIC accepted a settlement requiring a payment, a stop-sale for the products in the suits, and redesigns. Then it relaunched instead of disappearing.
RTIC could keep competing for the same customer. What it agreed to change was the product form that had made the comparison so immediate.
The lesson inside the cooler is simple: challenging a market leader's opportunity is not the same as securing the right to mirror its product identity.
Stay sharp, Stay curious. And always ask why, guys.
Follow the record.
What did this story make you question?
Comments are reviewed before they appear publicly. Your email is optional and never published.